JULIAN ZELIZER: Hey, everyone. Welcome back to Then and Now. I’m Julian Zelizer of The Long View.
JONATHAN ALTER: And I’m Jonathan Alter of Old Goats.
JULIAN: John, both of us have been following the news about AI, from security and education to jobs. There’s a lot of fear about what AI will do to white-collar and blue-collar work in the near future. It’s becoming a political issue and part of the midterms.
Naturally, I think back to the automation debates of the 1950s and ’60s, when people also feared what technology would do to jobs and livelihoods. How do you think about that period relative to where we are today?
JONATHAN: This is a perennial challenge in American history. If you go back to the early ’30s, a lot of people thought the Depression had been caused by automation. In fact, an early use of the phrase “New Deal” appeared in a New Republic article about how to deal with automation.
Then, in the ’50s, you had something like a second industrial revolution. Kurt Vonnegut, in his novel Player Piano, wondered whether we would ever survive a third revolution. “Industrial” isn’t quite the right word for what’s happening now, because AI also affects white-collar jobs.
The only honest answer is that we don’t know whether this time will be different. In the first two waves, you had what the economist Joseph Schumpeter called “creative destruction.” A lot of jobs were destroyed, but millions of new jobs emerged in new categories. Those jobs drew on creativity and thinking. AI threatens creative occupations, too, and that raises a whole new set of questions.
The good news is that there has been less displacement over the last three or four years than people assumed, and unemployment has not surged. But many people expect entry-level jobs in particular to become harder to get. Recent college graduates are already finding that. This doesn’t just affect high school graduates; it affects college graduates, too.
Gene Sperling, who was an economic adviser to Presidents Clinton, Obama, and Biden, thinks one answer is national service. Employers are finding that new hires who have spent some time out in the world after college—learning teamwork and different ways of thinking—can be more valuable than people who come straight out of college into jobs AI can easily handle. I’ve long favored national service for other reasons, but there may be an economic argument for it as well.
JULIAN: It’s a fascinating idea, and I’m sure we’ll pick up that discussion in the future. Thanks, John, as always. That was Then and Now. We’ll be back next week.
JONATHAN: Thanks, Julian.













